How to Get More Google Reviews Without Sounding Desperate

Playbook

Nov 1, 2025

Founding team, Olly

Customer leaving a review on a tablet at checkout
Customer leaving a review on a tablet at checkout
Customer leaving a review on a tablet at checkout

Asking for reviews feels awkward for most business owners and teams. It puts you in a vulnerable position, almost like you’re begging for validation. And yet, reviews are arguably one of the most powerful growth tools you have.

Today, most customers check your Google reviews before they check your website. They make decisions based not just on your product or pricing, but on other people’s experiences. And that means getting reviews isn't optional. It's essential.

The real question is: how do you ask for them without sounding pushy or desperate?

The answer isn’t just in what you say, it’s in when, where, and how you say it.


Why You Need More Reviews (Even If You Already Have Some)

It’s easy to feel like you have “enough” reviews. Maybe your page shows 4.3 stars. Maybe you’ve got 100+ responses on Google. That’s good, but it’s not enough.

What matters most is recency, volume, and consistency.

People don’t just want to see that someone liked your service last year, they want to know it’s still happening. A review from 2 weeks ago carries more weight than one from 2 years ago. And every new review pushes down the one old bad review that still shows up on your profile. So yes, getting more reviews matters. But getting them the right way matters more.


Make Reviews Part of the Journey, Not an Afterthought

The most common mistake businesses make is treating review requests like an awkward add-on at the end of the customer interaction. Instead, the goal is to build the review into the journey, as something that feels expected, not asked for.

Let’s say you run a salon. Instead of handing the customer a bill and then asking if they’d mind leaving a review, you bring a tablet to the counter that shows the invoice and, right before payment, prompts them with a quick review step:

“Before we close this out, we’d love a quick rating on your experience today.”

That’s it. No pressure. Just process. It’s not a favor. It’s part of how you close the loop. When you introduce review prompts as a normal step, it removes awkwardness. It becomes a habit, not a hustle.


Train Your Team to Ask Naturally, Not Rehearsed

Many frontline teams feel uncomfortable asking for reviews, because they’ve either been told to “just ask,” or they’ve had to deliver that old line:

“If you liked the experience, please leave us a 5-star review!”

That doesn’t work anymore. It feels scripted. Worse, it feels needy. Instead, train your team to ask in a way that centers the customer’s voice, not your rating. Something like:

“You’ll see a quick feedback screen at checkout, feel free to share anything that stood out today.”

or

“We’ve been trying to get better at learning from guests, your thoughts would really help.”

This frames the review as insight, not praise. It invites truth, not flattery. And that small shift makes all the difference in how it’s received.


Choose the Right Moment to Ask

Timing is everything when it comes to reviews. Ask too early, and the customer hasn’t processed their experience. Ask too late, and they’ve already moved on. The best time is right after a positive emotional moment, when the customer is smiling, saying thank you, or clearly satisfied.

That could be:

  • Just after a great treatment or service

  • When a customer compliments the staff

  • After a smooth problem resolution

  • At checkout, once the experience has landed well

Avoid asking when someone looks rushed, distracted, or underwhelmed. And definitely don’t ask while the experience is still in progress, it feels presumptive. When the moment feels right, the ask doesn’t feel like an ask at all.


Make It Ridiculously Easy

Even happy customers won’t leave a review if it’s hard. The moment there’s friction, needing to search your name, find the right link, log in, people drop off. You need to eliminate every possible barrier. Here’s what works:

  • A tablet at the counter with a built-in feedback prompt

  • A QR code at the table or on the bill

  • A short link in your WhatsApp or SMS follow-up

  • A review link in booking confirmations or thank-you emails

  • Auto-filled platform links (Google, Zomato, TripAdvisor) so they don’t have to search

Think of reviews like tipping: the easier it is to do in the moment, the more likely they are to do it.


Avoid These Common Mistakes

Even with good systems, some mistakes can tank your review flow. Here are three to avoid:

1. Asking for 5 stars
Customers should be invited to share honestly. Asking for 5 stars comes off as insecure and inauthentic.

2. Offering rewards or discounts
Most review platforms (like Google) ban incentivized reviews. But more importantly, it erodes the credibility of your reviews.

3. Making it about you
Avoid lines like “We’re trying to hit our review target!” or “Help us out!” It centers your goal instead of theirs.

Remember: customers don’t owe you a review. But if you create a great experience and a frictionless process, most will be happy to share.


Build a Culture, Not a Campaign

The businesses that consistently get high-quality reviews don’t treat this like a marketing push, they treat it like a mindset.

They talk about reviews in daily huddles.
They celebrate team members mentioned in feedback.
They update their processes based on real comments.

When your whole team values feedback, guests notice.
And when guests feel heard, they speak up more often.


Final Thoughts

You don’t need to sound desperate to get more reviews.
You need to be clear, consistent, and customer-focused.

Make it part of the journey.
Train your team to ask naturally.
Find the right moment.
And remove every ounce of friction.

Do that, and you won’t have to ask as often, people will want to share.

Coming Soon

Get early access

Be one of the first to use the most intelligent ORM tool

Coming Soon

Get early access

Be one of the first to use the most intelligent ORM tool

Coming Soon

Get early access

Be one of the first to use the most intelligent ORM tool

Stop the guesswork, and start knowing how your customers truly feel

© 2025 – askolly

Stop the guesswork, and start knowing how your customers truly feel

© 2025 – askolly

Stop the guesswork, and start knowing how your customers truly feel

© 2025 – askolly